National Coalition to Save Our Mall
view  view         

Home  •   Search  •   Newsletter/Archive  •   Contact Us   



DONATE

ABOUT THE COALITION
LETTER FROM THE PRESIDENT
   NEW October 2008

HISTORY AND RESOURCES
• Mall Maps
• Illustrated History
• Future of the Mall VIDEO
• 1902 McMillan Commission   Report

NATIONAL MALL THIRD CENTURY INITIATIVE

NATIONAL MALL CONSERVANCY

ANNUAL REPORTS
• 2006 Annual Report (PDF)
• 2005 Annual Report (PDF)

GREAT MOMENTS
PHOTO GALLERY
• Who's in Charge?

THE MALL CHRONICLES
• Media Coverage
• Analysis
• Coalition Testimony
• Letters

THE WWII MEMORIAL
• WWII Memorial Archive

WASHINGTON MONUMENT
• Washington Monument Archive  Updated 8/8/2008

U.S. CAPITOL

THREATS & TREATS
ACT NOW
• What You Can Do
• Contribute

WHO WE ARE
WWII Veterans
PRESSROOM
Detailed Search



The World War II Memorial

How the Site Was Chosen

The Rainbow Pool on the Mall, the most famous, historic open space in America, was approved as the site for the World War II Memorial -- and an original off-axis Mall site was quickly discarded -- without any public debate or awareness and without adequate public notice.

The public learned of the key vote only after the vote was taken by the Commission of Fine Arts (CFA) in Washington, D.C., one of two federal bodies responsible for reviewing public construction in the Nation's Capital.

Site Selection

Graphic from ABC's World News Tonight, 6/4/00, 6:00 pm

Ambassador F. Haydn Williams, the director of the Memorial construction project, boasted: "The site was approved before they knew what hit them. Then they came out of the woodwork" (TALK Magazine, November 1999).

The colossal 7.4-acre Memorial will deface the idyllic 90-year old Rainbow Pool site with a granite plaza and break the great sweep of open space and vistas connecting the Washington Monument and Lincoln Memorial, the nation's two most prominent memorials.

Here are the facts. Congress authorized construction of the World War II Memorial in 1993 and directed the American Battle Monuments Commission (ABMC) to build it. The National Park Service (NPS) started the process by identifying six potential sites -- but the Rainbow Pool was not among them.

As required by federal law, the National Capital Planning Commission (NCPC) voted -- at the request of the ABMC -- to locate the Memorial on the Mall near the Vietnam Memorial on July 25, 1995. Next, the Commission on Fine Arts (CFA) also was required to vote on the site. But on September 19, 1995 -- in a surprise move -- the CFA voted to shift the Memorial to the Rainbow Pool.

Until that day, no one had dared to suggest disturbing the historic open area of the Mall which has been called "one of the world's premier examples of civic art, which itself is a monument to democracy." The audacious land grab was proposed for the first time, then approved minutes later on the same day -- without allowing the public any time to comment. The backroom maneuvering continued when on October 5, 1995 - only 17 days later -- the NCPC changed direction and voted for the Rainbow Pool site as well.

The public notices for the two meetings failed to alert the public to this disaster for the Mall and did not mention the Rainbow Pool site -- an egregious violation of the public trust. Apparently the sponsors felt that the American people would rebel, had they been consulted.

In an article in The New York Times, April 4, 1999, James S. Russell cited the lack of debate on the location of the question of World War II Memorial. "Had such a debate occurred, the Mall axis might well have been deemed the wrong place for a war memorial, however important the conflict," he said.

We need your help to force Congress to conduct a fair and open debate on the merits of this site, as well as the design (see "Irreconcilable Differences" below). It's not too late but we can't win our fight without your help. Please contact your United States Representative and two United States Senators today. With your help will stop this process cold in its tracks then start the process of building a Memorial that all Americans -- especially our veterans -- will view with pride!

Back to the top




The World War II Memorial
• Timeline
• The Design
• The Controversy
• What We Proposed
• Why We Fight On
• Environmental Risks
• Article Outlines Risks
• Letters
   • EPA
   • DC Governemt
   • Park Police
   • Council on Environmental Quality
• Construction Photos

Copyright © 2008 National Coalition to Save Our Mall Inc. All Rights Reserved