National Coalition to Save Our Mall
view  view         

Home  •   Search  •   Newsletter/Archive  •   Contact Us   



PLEASE HELP US MEET A NEW MATCHING GRANT

LETTER FROM THE PRESIDENT
   October 30, 2007

THE MALL
• Mall Maps
• Illustrated History
• Future of the Mall VIDEO

NATIONAL MALL THIRD CENTURY INITIATIVE

ANNUAL REPORTS
• 2006 Annual Report (PDF)
• 2005 Annual Report (PDF)

GREAT MOMENTS
PHOTO GALLERY
• Who's in Charge?

THE MALL CHRONICLES
• Media Coverage
• Analysis
• Coalition Testimony
• Letters

THE WWII MEMORIAL
• WWII Memorial Archive

WASHINGTON MONUMENT
• Washington Monument Archive

U.S. CAPITOL

THREATS & TREATS
ACT NOW
• What You Can Do
• Contribute

WHO WE ARE
WWII Veterans
PRESSROOM
Detailed Search



What We Proposed

The National Coalition proposed a win-win solution that would have both produced a WWII Memorial much sooner than the current 2003 or 2004 completion date and preserved the Mall.

Our Proposal

The National Coalition to Save Our Mall supports a win-win solution that protects and preserves the National Mall and appropriately memorializes World War II and those whose sacrifices have perpetuated freedom and democracy.

Whereas ...
1. The World War II memorial will commemorate the most important event of the 20th Century. Because of its size and location, the proposed memorial will be as significant as the Washington Monument or the Lincoln Memorial.

2. The memorial plan has caused a national controversy because the proposal includes a 7.4-acre edifice in the middle of the National Mall with 56 pillars and a 6-foot sunken pit. It would destroy the 2-mile open sweep of the Mall on a site between the Washington Monument and Lincoln Memorial (called "the Rainbow Pool") placing a barrier between these two symbols of our democracy. It would block the historic "March on Washington," "Million Mom March", "Hands Across America" path.

3. The New York Times, USA Today, The Wall Street Journal, Newsweek, the Los Angeles Times, The New Yorker, the Atlanta Constitution, The Nation, columnists George Will, Charles Krauthammer, Jonathan Yardley and numerous regional newspapers have all criticized the proposed site and design since 1997.

4. A federal lawsuit is pending in U.S. District Court because federal agencies failed to:
  • Ensure the memorial's location would not interfere with other monuments on the Mall as required by the Commemorative Works Act signed by President Ronald Reagan.
  • Evaluate the environmental impact of the site and design as required by the National Environmental Policy Act.
  • Provide the public and other federal agencies a credible opportunity to comment on the site and design.
5. Recent passage of legislation to expedite the Memorial, signed by the President on Memorial Day, establishes a historically dangerous precedent in our government, circumventing all federal laws and procedures. This is now creating even more controversy and unresolved bitterness.

Now therefore, we propose the following Win-Win Solution

Rebuild and restore the historic Rainbow Pool as the Memorial contemplative area and perhaps add new benches, following guidelines in the National Park Service's Cultural Landscape Report for the Lincoln Memorial Grounds. This first stage could be completed by Memorial Day 2002.

Build a World War II Memorial at another prominent site. One possible location is in Constitution Gardens (17th St. and Constitution Ave.) 100 ft. to the north, a site unanimously approved in 1995 by American Battle Monuments Commission and National Capital Planning Commission.

Build a World War II Museum on one of the 100+ sites identified in the National Capital Planning Commission's Memorials and Museums Master Plan. For more information on NCPC's Memorials Master Plan, visit www.ncpc.gov

Back to the top




The World War II Memorial
• Timeline
• The Design
• The Controversy
• What We Proposed
• Why We Fight On
• Environmental Risks
• Article Outlines Risks
• Letters
   • EPA
   • DC Governemt
   • Park Police
   • Council on Environmental Quality
• Construction Photos

Copyright © 2004 National Coalition to Save Our Mall Inc. All Rights Reserved