National Coalition to Save Our Mall
view  view         

Home  •   Search  •   Newsletter/Archive  •   Contact Us   



DONATE

ABOUT THE COALITION
LETTER FROM THE PRESIDENT
   October 30, 2007

HISTORY AND RESOURCES
• Mall Maps
• Illustrated History
• Future of the Mall VIDEO
• 1902 McMillan Commission   Report

NATIONAL MALL THIRD CENTURY INITIATIVE

NATIONAL MALL CONSERVANCY

ANNUAL REPORTS
• 2006 Annual Report (PDF)
• 2005 Annual Report (PDF)

GREAT MOMENTS
PHOTO GALLERY
• Who's in Charge?

THE MALL CHRONICLES
• Media Coverage
• Analysis
• Coalition Testimony
• Letters

THE WWII MEMORIAL
• WWII Memorial Archive

WASHINGTON MONUMENT
• Washington Monument Archive  Updated 8/8/2008

U.S. CAPITOL

THREATS & TREATS
ACT NOW
• What You Can Do
• Contribute

WHO WE ARE
WWII Veterans
PRESSROOM
Detailed Search



May 1, 2008

Dear Friends,

In today's Washington Post columnist Marc Fisher highlights two young tour guides on the National Mall.   Ben and Brody were part of last week's WalkingTown DC as well.  Their website is http://www.DCbyfoot.com

Our own Mall walking tour last weekend was a great success, drawing 55 people to learn "What the Memorials Don't Tell You," subtitled "I Have a Dream:  The Struggle for Freedom in America."

RAW FISHER
by Marc Fisher

Tour Guide Revolution: Working For Tips

With a little bit of rap (about King George III, of all people: "He was a meany and we were so teeny"), a healthy but not overbearing dose of history and a whole lot of nerve, two recent college graduates are rattling the genteel world of Washington tour guides.

Ben Hindman and Brody Davis are giving tours for free.

Working only for tips, the two friends in bright orange caps are attracting tourists who find themselves on the Mall knowing little more than that the really tall one has to do with Washington; the squat, columned one is where Forrest Gump liked to hang out; and the one with the dome is where the president lives, or something like that.

"A lot of tourists really don't know anything about Washington or history," Hindman says. "We thought we could entertain people and get them interested in history at the same time."

Not entertained are the city's professional guides, who "really don't like us," says Hindman, 24, a Bostonian who found the inspiration for DC By Foot in Berlin, where he took a tour from a tips-only guide.

"This has been their livelihood, and they don't like us giving it away," Davis says. "They are professionals, and they think we don't know anything."

Actually, says Tom Whitley, who handles marketing for the Guild of Professional Tour Guides of Washington, D.C., "it would be foolhardy for highly skilled guides to get into some kind of a fight with people trying to pick up tours out on the street. Let's just say that it's much more likely that a person who wants a qualified guide will go out and get a professional guide."

The guild's code of ethics frowns upon soliciting for tips. Hindman and Davis figure their business is the ultimate expression of capitalism. They offer a service; people determine its value and pay accordingly.

Although traditional guides say they provide accurate and compelling stories about Washington and the nation's great symbols, the two buddies fresh out of Vanderbilt University say they checked out the competition and were underwhelmed.

"We went on the other tours, and they were really pretty boring," says Davis, 22, who worked as an intern for senators Bill Frist and Joe Lieberman before diving into the tour business.

So Hindman and Davis studied up, obtained D.C. tour guide licenses and asked their former history professors to share favorite Washington stories.

They concocted a script mixing the standard tales of heroism and nation-building (the birth of lobbying at the Willard Hotel, the stirring John Adams-Thomas Jefferson friendship, the strange but true explanation of why the Washington Monument is two-toned) with wacky bits that would probably come only from the minds of kids fresh out of college.

For example, your average professional guide, while summarizing the Revolutionary War, probably doesn't ask tour groups to "march like you're British" and lead the tourists skipping down the path.

"More than anything else, I want the tour to be factual," says Davis, who recalls hearing guides on other tours tell about how when the elevator in the Washington Monument first opened to the public, authorities tried to overcome public fears of the newfangled machine by offering free whiskey to any man brave enough to ride the car up and back. Davis says he "found out there was no way the government would offer whiskey to people and no ban on women and children riding the elevator."

So Davis instead tells the (true) story of Gabby Street. On an August morning in 1908, the catcher for the Washington Senators caught a baseball dropped from the top of the Monument, pocketed a $500 prize, walked away dazed by the impact and went on to catch Walter Johnson's pitching in a 3-1 victory over Detroit that day.

If the professionals are disturbed by the introduction of free tours on the Mall, they are smart enough to keep their carping to a minimum, in part because they don't think the free model will survive. Hindman and Davis sometimes have their doubts, too.

Since they started last summer, they have given more than 100 tours, averaging more than 35 people per outing and collecting about $150 from each group. A family of four is often happy to fork over a $20 tip rather than the $15 per person -- or much more -- they might have to pay for a traditional tour.

"That paid the rent and let us hibernate for the winter," Hindman says. Along the way, they figured out that foreigners tip better; that the larger the group, the lower the per capita tip; and that nothing gins up business better than making nice to hotel concierges (this is, after all, the capital of lobbying.) But some concierges prefer to recommend only tours that deliver a commission for sending business their way -- a step the DC By Foot guys say they can't afford.

For now, Hindman and Davis are getting by. They'd love to turn their business into a permanent fixture on the Mall, but they're hedging their bets. Davis plans to go to law school, and Hindman to business school. Turns out there's something to this idea of being a professional.

Back to the top




Mall Updates

2008
• Aug. 14: Examiner & Wash Times: MLK Memorial
• Aug. 2: Permits on the mall?
• Aug. 1: Suggestions for Reflecting Pool
• July 31: Examiner: Mall Sprawl and Norton
• July 29: Examiner: Capitol Reflecting Pool
• July 18: Newsweek: Mall Overhaul
• July 13: Post: Editorial
• July 10: Post: NCPC
• July 8: NPS & NCPC update
• July 7: Rethinking Washington's Monumental Core
• July 4: WMAL-AM & WDCW TV: Feldman
• July 4: Dallas Morning News: Mall
• July 2: CBS News: Gone to Seed reaction
• June 27: CBS News: Feldman
• June 20: Post: Toles' toon
• June 18: Post: Trust for Mall
• June 16: Smithsonian Program
• June 5: National Mall Conservancy
• May 29: NPS meeting on levee system
• May 26: Post: Editorial on National Mall
• May 21: Post: Hearing on the National Mall
• May 19: Hearing on The Future of the National Mall
• May 15: Hearing on The Future of the National Mall
• May 8: Walking Tour: I Have A Dream
• May 6: Post & LA Times: Smithsonian
• May 1: Post: Fisher column
• Apr. 29: Atherton Memorial Lecture
• Apr. 25: WalkingTown, DC
• Apr. 11: WalkingTown, DC
• Apr. 9: Cleveland Park Citizens meeting
• Apr. 7: Cherry Blossoms
• Mar. 27: Guide to Mall Rec
• Mar. 11: Fox 5: Feldman
• Mar. 10: Post: Fisher column
• Feb. 29: Mall items of note
• Feb. 28: Raw Fisher Radio: Feldman
• Feb. 25: NCMAC meeting
• Feb. 18: President's Day links
• Feb. 12: NBM hosts Judith Dupre
• Feb. 10: Kojo Nnamdi Show: Feldman
• Feb. 8: Bloomberg: critic Russell
• Feb. 6: Post: NCPC
• Feb. 4: Post Magazine: Lincoln Memorial
• Jan. 27: Where Magazine: Editorial
• Jan. 25: Tom Sherwood comments
• Jan. 24: Post; FEMA maps
• Jan. 21: Mall management plan

2007
• Dec. 28: Public meetings
• Nov. 28: Vietnam Center review
• Nov. 16: Trust for the Mall
• Nov. 12: USA Today: Vietnam Center
• Nov. 5: AP: Arts & Industries Building
• Nov. 1: Help meet the grant
• Oct. 31: St. Elizabeths Hospital
• Oct. 29: Help meet the grant
• Oct. 22: NCMAC meeting
• Oct. 19: Post; Vietnam Center
• Oct. 18: Wash Times; Mall expansion
• Oct. 17: Vietnam Center approval
• Oct. 15: NPS Ranger lecture
• Oct. 12: Wash Times; Vietnam Center
• Sept. 25: Walking tours
• Sept. 17: NPS Announces Mall EIS
• Sept. 6: Lecture: Designing the Capital
• Aug. 2: New Mall Recreation Guide
• June 25: Post: "shortsighted planning"
• June 19: Post: Jefferson Memorial
• June 6: DCPL Most Endangered Places
• June 12: Senator Craig Thomas passing
• May 30: Post: Historical Society defunding
• May 26: Memorial Day coverage
• Apr. 29: Post: The Awakening
• Apr. 17: Coverage of April 11 Symposium
• Apr. 16: Post and Wash Times coverage
• Apr. 13: WalkingTown, DC
• Apr. 4: NCPC symposium
• Mar. 22: NPS Listening Session
• Mar. 8: NCPC extends comments
• Mar. 7: Atherton Memorial Lecture
• Mar. 5: NW Current piece
• Mar. 2: NCPC flood draft
• Feb. 17: National Mall Plan meetings
• Feb. 15: America's Favorite Architecture
• Feb. 13: History Lecture postponed
• Feb. 6: San Fran Chron: Letters
• Feb. 2: NMAAHC comments
• Jan. 19: National Mall Plan comments
• Jan. 15: Overbeck History Lecture
• Jan. 12: Feldman on CBS Sunday Morning
• Jan. 3: NCPC public meeting
• Jan. 2: NMAAHC meeting

2006
• Dec. 28: Comments deadlines
• Dec. 22: Donate to help
• Dec. 7: Wash Times and Post coverage
• Dec. 6: Post: Editorial
• Nov. 21: NPS Environmental Assessment
• Nov. 16: Future of the Mall Symposium
• Nov. 7: Post: Fisher
• Nov. 6: SM welcomes NPS Symposium
• Nov. 4: Feldman on NPR
• Oct. 31: Peter Penczer lecture
• Oct. 19: Help meet the grant
• Oct. 12: LA Times; Whalen Obit
• Sept. 27: Slate; Visitor Center
• Sept. 26: Smithsonian Associates Program
• Sept. 25: Wash Times; Eisenhower memorial
• Sept. 18: Post; Eisenhower memorial
• Sept. 12: Contact Congress
• Sept. 9: LA Times: Christopher Knight
• Sept. 5: Open Park on Mall
• Sept. 4: Post: Roger K. Lewis
• Aug. 14: NYT; Editorial
• Aug. 9: WETA's "The Intersection"
• Aug. 7: Post/Examiner on Visitor Center
• July 20: NCPC Framework Plan
• July 17: LA Times: Tyler Green
• July 11: July Study Tour
• July 6: Washingtonian: Arthur Cotton Moore
• June 13: Dallas Morning News coverage
• June 3: Atherton tribute
• June 1: Post; Mall expansion
• May 31: Comment on the EA
• May 29: WWI Memorial
• May 27: Wash Times; Dietsch piece
• May 19: Roll Call; Visitor Center
• May 18: NCPC & Norton expansion
• May 12: Visitor Center mandate
• May 9: Post; Smithsonian endangered
• May 8: 2005 Annual Report
• Apr. 11: Immigrants rally coverage
• Apr. 1: Project for Public Spaces
• Mar. 31: Post; Dvorak on Wall
• Mar. 30: Cherry Blossoms
• Mar. 10: Hawkins at NBM
• Mar. 9: Visitor Center on Mall
• Feb. 6: NYT; Clemetson piece
• Jan. 31: NYT, Post, WTimes, Examiner
• Jan. 13: Mall map progress
• Jan. 9: NBM invite
• Jan. 7: GW Speakers Series invite

2005
• Dec. 20: Post; Correction
• Dec. 16: Wash Times; Letter
• Dec. 12: Post; Editorial
• Dec. 9: Post; Dvorak piece
• Dec. 6: Post; Atherton passing
• Nov. 28: Dallas Morning News coverage
• Nov. 28: Post; Cooper letter
• Nov. 22: Free Map mailing
• Nov. 10: Examiner; DeWitt piece
• Nov. 8: Interactive maps online/Post piece
• Oct. 20: Corcoran presentation
• Oct. 5: Future of Mall video online
• Sept. 22: Architectural Record piece
• Aug. 31: Mall tour sold out
• Aug. 29: Smithsonian Mall tour
• Aug. 22: Weekly Standard available
• Aug. 10: Weekly Standard piece
• Aug. 7: Post; Metro piece
• July 22: Post; Editorial
• June 16: Free Mall Map/Guide
• May 13: Smithsonian WiFi
• May 9: Kojo Nnamdi Show
• Apr. 13: Fax to Senate
• Apr. 12: Coalition Senate Testimony
• Apr. 11: Post; Feldman Letter
• Mar. 23: Mall oversight hearing
• Mar. 21: Post; Hiatt Op-Ed
• Mar. 4: Mall PowerPoint at NCPC
• Feb. 18: Mall PowerPoint at CFA
• Feb. 16: CFA public session
• Feb. 14: Contact Congress
• Jan. 26: Bloomberg; Ferguson column
• Jan. 13: Post; Letters/NBC 4
• Jan. 10: Post; Hiatt column
• Jan. 9: Post; Letter
• Jan. 5: Post; Letters
• Jan. 4: Post; Editorial
• Jan. 2: Post; Hsu piece

2004
• Dec. 30: Post; Oberlander letter
• Dec. 26: Year end greetings
• Dec. 9: AP; Hartman piece
• Dec. 7: NW Current piece
• Nov. 29: Post; Lee/Hsu pieces
• Nov. 22: National Mall invite
• Oct. 15: USA Today; Dietsch piece
• Oct. 2: Post; Moore/Cooper letters
• Sept. 21: WWII Mem; Knight/Mill's book
• Sept. 15: Post; Trescott piece
• Sept. 9: Post; Milloy column
• Aug. 14: Passonneau book
• Aug. 11: Workshop reports
• July 3: Judy on ABC
• June 30: NBM Mill's talk info
• June 28: NBM Mill's talk
• June 24: WWII Mem; Knight
• June 22: City Museum Lecture
• June 21: WWII Mem; Wise
• June 18: WWII Mem; Ivey
• June 14: WWII Mem; Gopnik
• May 10: Wash Times; column
• May 7: Workshop II
• May 4: Post; Fisher WWII Mem.
• Apr. 6: Wash Times' Hudson
• Apr. 1: Post; Hsu on fence
• Mar. 27: Post; front page
• Mar. 19: Workshop prep
• Mar. 2: Mall Conservancy news
• Feb. 19: Judge Collyer decision
• Feb. 15: Post; Berard letter
• Feb. 3: Meetings/WWII Mem. stories
• Jan. 27: Post; Reel piece
• Jan. 15: Post; Reel piece
• Jan. 13: Mall Conservancy forum
• Jan. 12: 2004 Scholars Program

2003
• Jan. 7
• Jan. 9
• Jan. 10
• Jan. 20
• Jan. 30
• Feb. 3
• Feb. 25
• Mar. 10
• Mar. 17
• Apr. 4
• Apr. 20
• May 2
• June 6
• June 16
• June 23
• July 2
• July 20a
• July 20b
• Aug. 28
• Sept. 4
• Sept. 5
• Sept. 14
• Sept. 23
• Sept. 28a
• Sept. 28b
• Oct. 2
• Oct. 5
• Oct. 6
• Oct. 14
• Oct. 17
• Oct. 19
• Oct. 22
• Oct. 23
• Oct. 27
• Nov. 8
• Nov. 10
• Nov. 13
• Nov. 14
• Nov. 20
• Nov. 21
• Dec. 6
• Dec. 28

2002
• July 1
• July 4
• July 19
• July 23
• July 24-a
• July 24-b
• July 30
• Aug. 2
• Aug. 10
• Sept. 11
• Sept. 20
• Oct. 17
• Nov. 11
• Nov. 26
• Dec. 6


Copyright © 2008 National Coalition to Save Our Mall Inc. All Rights Reserved